Response & Protest
by Ashish Joy
As we exist, we continue to find or produce meaning and purpose in all that we be, do, and relate. By meaning I speak of the reasons by which we have found ourselves in this present moment as we look to the past; by purpose I speak of the overwhelming desires of the soul and where direction pulls us as we look to the future from our present moment. Meaning is a response to the paths we have walked on, while purpose is a protest to the present as we walk towards our tomorrow. Meaning looks backward, while purpose looks forward. Response and protest are the constant flux we find ourselves in as we seek to exist. Organisms are in a constant state of imbalance in a given environment (that is what makes something ‘alive’), and our response and protest are what gives us humans the power to exist in our given environments.
In our existence we construct these realities. The response we come to might be deserved, imagined, false, or quite necessary. The protest we claim might be high-minded, self-seeking, humble, and maybe sacrificial. We come to these realities of meaning and purpose, or response and protest, in our lives through our being, doing, and relating.
Meaning and purpose find their hermeneutic in the human psyche. We seek to explain our reality, whether it be in our response or in protest, in each present moment. In a given moment we find ourselves responders to the immediate and distant past, and protesters to the immediate and distant future. There is immeasurable potential in each given moment. It is in a simple moment that we can respond and protest our existence.
What seems to be the constant problem with us humans is that we fail in our responding and protesting. In our responding we might respond to a thing not needing a response, or respond erroneously to something that required a response. In our protesting we might protest a thing was quite necessary in our lives, or fail to protest something that was never meant to be a part of our lives.
In our failures to respond and protest correctly we bear our greatest challenges, struggles, and burdens. It is the power of response and protest in a moment, and the effect of our collective responses and protests in our lifetime that define us. Specifically they affect our being, doing, and relating.
In the thick of all of this, I want to speak of peace and chaos. Peace is the reality of one’s correct responses and protests. Peace is where meaning and purpose have found its place in one’s life. Stating it another way, one may find peace in responding correctly to the past, and rightfully protesting the future. Peace is not a change of affairs. Peace cannot change the past, nor can it always bring about a desired future. Peace rather is a state of being, doing, and relating. Peace flows from within, though it is affected by what is from without. Chaos, contrary to peace, is the reality of one’s incorrect response and protests. Chaos implies that meaning and purpose have been displaced in a person’s life. Chaos in one’s life does not imply natural chaos. It is rather a state of being, doing, and relating. One can be in the calmest environment and still be in complete chaos, because he/she has responded incorrectly to the past and continues to incorrectly protest their future.
Our lives move between responding and protesting correctly or incorrectly. Though we may desire constant peace in our lives, it is hard to grasp. This is because there is always something that displaces our correct responses and protests. We are not perfect in this endeavour, though we may try.
Comments
I like the last two paragraphs about peace. It is so true. My thoughts on peace are that when my back is not aligned there is an unhealthy or impairing muscular tension and pain. After getting the back adjusted there is an alignment and hence a “peace” within the muscular structures because each muscle, bone and nerve are in agreement with each other.
When meaning, purpose, and other things are in agreement with each other, there’s peace. Together I can move with a sense of purpose, meaning.
I hope that made sense. I was thinking out loud. Good writing as always
thanks for the response Indu… I’m glad it made sense. A writer always wonders if he makes sense
Yeah, us especially fiction writers. So when am I going to see your books in print?
I am really enjoying your thoughts on life, faith, understanding, and existence. So, first, thank you for sharing.
I am finding in myself an interesting paradox in concordance with what you say about response and protest, specifically protest.
As we strive for something, or purpose as you would say, we most oft believe to be striving for something noble. It is hardly heard that one is striving to be the worst possible person. However, in my protest towards reaching whatever perceived noble goal, I am in essence failing to protest.
For example, if I were to strive for humility (or if humility was my purpose). My quest, is in itself self-defeating. For, how can one be humble while claiming humility?
In “response”
to your analogy of chaos and peace. I also have to ask if chaos cannot be a good thing? If my response and protest are correct, then you say it leads to peace. But what if proper response and protest lead to chaos?
For if I am in a current state of being, doing, and relating. To protest, is in essence to rebel against the current state. To throw my being into chaos. If the current state has yet more to protest, I would say there must be a healthy dose of chaos, in order to protest against the current state. For the state that we are striving to change simply does not enter into peace. It must first be disturbed in order to be changed.
Just thoughts.
Ian:
I understand where you’re coming from. On reading this post further I realize that protest could be thought of in a rebellious, subversive light. I do think I should clarify protest.
Protest, in my opinion, is what we humans do in life to exist. When we think, we protest a reality that seeks to assert itself in our minds. When we say something, we speak into a reality that is already headed in some direction, but we change that by what we say. When we do something, we move the current reality we find ourselves.
When I use the word protest I am thinking of the overarching idea that fundamentally as humans we are both responding to the past and protesting the future.
When I spoke of peace I tried to focus it on the individual rather than the situation. When our responses and protests are correct we find ourselves in a state of peace; while we find ourselves in chaos if our responses and protests are wrong. Peace has everything to do with what’s going on inside of you the individual and I believe chaos does as well.
I think I understand what you mean by chaos/disturbance working in a given environment to eventually create change/peace. I would agree…
I think at some point, I’d like to write of peace and chaos from a social, group-based perspective. That would be fun